Issue #2: Busy systems vs empty schools
Wellbeing systems are working hard, but many schools still feel like they're running out of energy. What sits beneath that tension, and one small shift that can start to change it.
From the Cohere archive. Cohere is now sent monthly.
Welcome to Issue #2 of Cohere – our first edition built around a single pattern of practice.
This fortnight, we're looking at something many educators across the Alliance are experiencing right now: wellbeing systems that are working hard, but schools that still feel like they're running out of energy. We explore what sits beneath this tension – and one small shift that can start to change it.
"Students who experience a stronger sense of belonging at school are more likely to engage positively with learning and less likely to experience loneliness and disengagement."
— OECD PISA 2022, Australian Results
The Pattern We're Seeing
Fires everywhere – but the ecosystem isn't changing
Across schools, one pattern that continues to emerge in conversations with leaders and teachers is that educators are working incredibly hard to respond to increasing levels of anxiety, dysregulation, disengagement and behavioural complexity.
Schools have developed layered wellbeing systems, intervention processes and behaviour plans, yet many educators still describe feeling as though they are constantly 'putting out fires' and running out of energy in the process.
Recent Australian evidence from PISA, ACARA attendance data, Mission Australia's Youth Survey and NSW CESE research indicates that many students continue to experience inconsistent connection, belonging and engagement at school – with belonging strongly linked to attendance, wellbeing, relationships, motivation and achievement.
The tension may be that wellbeing has increasingly become intervention-driven, focused heavily on responding to challenge, rather than intentionally creating the conditions that help young people truly flourish.
What Sits Beneath It
The lens we've inherited
Much of modern schooling has traditionally been shaped through a pathogenic lens: identifying risk, deficits, symptoms and "what's wrong?" While these approaches remain important, they can unintentionally narrow the conversation toward fixing problems rather than building holistic health.
The pathogenic lens trains us to see what is broken first – the missing skill, the rule that was not followed, the plan that needs another tier. What it does not help us see is what young people are quietly asking for: a day that feels predictable, relationships that hold steady, and a sense that what is happening around them is comprehensible. When the only language available is the language of risk, the slow work of building belonging, safety and meaning tends to stay invisible – and what stays invisible rarely gets resourced. Comprehensibility is the part of the puzzle we are usually missing: helping students (and staff) make sense of what is happening to them and around them.
Why This Matters
Wellbeing as creation, not correction
What is often left unnamed is the need for schools to deliberately cultivate protective factors such as belonging, agency, meaning, connection and hope in everyday learning environments.
When educators begin to understand that wellbeing is not simply the absence of problems, but the active creation of conditions that support flourishing, the conversation starts to shift.
A pathogenic system keeps pulling people out of the river, while a salutogenic system teaches people how to swim – and also asks why the river is so difficult to navigate in the first place.
— Aaron Antonovsky
One Small Shift
One question. A different conversation.
One practical shift schools can trial this week is changing a single reflective question used in classrooms, meetings or wellbeing conversations.
Instead of: "What is wrong here?"
Try asking: "What helps this student feel capable, connected and hopeful?"
This small adjustment immediately shifts attention toward strengths, protective factors and possibilities for growth.
Teams may even choose to audit one existing wellbeing or behaviour practice and ask: does this primarily focus on reducing problems, or intentionally building connection, agency and belonging?
Across the Alliance
What happened when one team changed its language
Across several SSA partner schools this term, teams have been exploring how small, intentional relational shifts can influence student engagement and classroom culture in meaningful ways.
One team reflected on the impact of intentionally changing the language used during student check-ins and behaviour coaching conversations. Staff began shifting away from compliance-focused "Why?" questions – "Why did you do that?" – toward more reflective and relational "What?" questions – "Tell me more about what was happening and what you were hoping for."
"Why" questions can direct students toward defensiveness. "What" questions invite curiosity, self-evaluation and problem-solving.
This creates greater space for regulation, reflection and responsibility.
Rather than focusing solely on behaviour correction, staff began using conversations to strengthen connection, capability and student agency. Importantly, the change did not come from introducing another program – it came from intentionally strengthening the everyday relational conditions that help students feel seen, valued, connected and successful.
We hope this first pattern of practice gives you something concrete to take into your week. We would love to hear what you notice when you try the shift.
See you in two weeks.
The SSA team
More from Cohere